How Sticky Will Stickybits Be?

In our lengthy coverage of QR codes and barcode marketing in general, we’ve repeatedly referenced Stickybits without ever diving into how the platform actually works. There’s a reason for that – a couple, actually. But, with Doritos, Pepsi, Ben & Jerry’s, and other CPG giants flirting with the service, we certainly owe them a glance here on The Awesome Blog.

Stickybits is a smartphone application that allows users to attach content to pre-existing barcodes, and access content that other people have left on the same code. That “pre-existing” part is the key; Stickybits turns any product with a UPC (so, uh, basically any product) into a social media channel. The brand often delivers the first “bit” of content, much like other barcode applications. For instance, a clever campaign from Food52 partnered with brands like Domino’s sugar and Organic Valley Sour Cream to provide recipes when users scanned the UPC on each product’s package. However, consumers can then respond by attaching their own mp3s, videos, text, pdfs, and what-have-you to the UPC for anyone to see. Imagine the possibilities for abuse!

And that‘s exactly why we’ve been hesitant to jump on board. In the era of Consumer Controlled Conversations, we all know that marketers have to engage in open, honest dialogs with consumers in public forums. But monitoring Twitter conversations is one thing; having consumers tearing your brand apart on a forum that’s attached to your physical product can, understandably, be a tough pill for clients to swallow. Sure, consumers can have these conversations with or without your involvement, but if you’re not calling attention to your UPC, most consumers probably aren’t even going to think to scan the code in the first place.

Which brings us to problem number two with Stickybits. As we mentioned in the QR code Smartshont webinar, one benefit of a QR code is that consumers always know that there’s some content on the other end of the code – it’s essentially a sign that there’s something more to see. With Stickybits, your campaign is relying on a UPC that’s generally ignored unless you explicitly call attention to it via packaging, in-store media, or some other touchpoint. Are consumers really going to go around scanning every UPC in the supermarket looking for content? Of course not, which means unprompted conversations will almost certainly come from extreme fans and extreme haters. By no means is that a deal-killer for Stickybits, but it’s worth considering.

For instance, it makes perfect sense for Campbell’s new campaign to utilize the Stickybits platform, because the campaign itself is explicitly about the redesigned labels for their soup cans. (Campbell’s is dangling a $500 sweepstakes to encourage participation.) This is a clear example of connecting the medium to the message (and the product, for that matter), so the item being discussed doubles as the platform for the discussion. Also, by giving consumers a specific topic to discuss, it’s likely that Campbell’s has pre-emptively reigned in some of the more “colorful” anonymous comments that are to be expected in the age of Consumer Controlled Conversations.

Coke’s application of Stickybits uses similar logic. Part of their mysterious campaign surrounding the brand’s secret recipe includes “unlocking the bottle,” communicating to consumers that there might be a reason to scan the codes on the product. (P.S. There’s a fun little trick hidden in that linked Coke video – let us know if you haven’t found it yet.)

So, where does this leave us? Frankly, on the fence. It’s a compelling platform, as evidenced by the three campaigns above. There are certainly good applications in the right situation, and the Food52 example offers a particularly innovative partnership strategy. However, for now, there are also considerable risks and shortcomings, many of which can be avoided using other barcode and social media solutions. We’ll certainly stick around and see how the situation develops.

If you haven’t already, please don’t forget to vote for our SXSW 2011 panel, accessible here. You’ll need to create an account to vote, but we promise that it takes less than a minute. Voting closes Friday, August 27th, and we appreciate every bit of help we can get!